If you’ve ever swapped your usual road loop for a local trail, you’ve probably noticed something: trail running feels different. Your heart rate climbs, your pace drops, and your legs work in ways they don’t on smooth tarmac.
But is trail running actually harder than road running or just a different kind of challenge? Here are the key differences, the benefits of each, and why running off-road might just make you a stronger and even a happier runner.
Why Does Trail Running Feel Harder Than Road Running?
1. Uneven Terrain Works More Muscles
Roads are predictable: flat, firm, and consistent. Trails? Not so much. You’re constantly adjusting to roots, rocks, mud and uneven ground.
This engages stabilising muscles in your calves, ankles, hips and core — muscles that don’t work nearly as hard on the road.
Biomechanics research has shown that uneven terrain increases muscle activation and ground contact time, meaning your body is doing more work even if your pace is slower.
So while you might be running slower, you’re definitely not working less.
2. Hills Are Hard (And That’s A Good Thing!)
Most trails involve hills. Sometimes they are short, punchy climbs, other times they are long, grinding ascents. Even a small incline can raise your heart rate significantly compared to running the same effort on flat ground.
Trail running can be 30–90 seconds per kilometre (one or two minutes per mile) slower than on the road, depending on elevation and how challenging the terrain is (even on relatively flat routes or gravel paths we naturally run slower on trails). It’s not that you’re less fit — it’s that the conditions demand more from you.
And don’t ignore the downhills. While you might fly down them, the eccentric load – hitting the ground with your leg straight and quad muscle contracted – can really take it out of your thighs on a longer or faster run.
3. It’s Mentally More Engaging
Trail running isn’t just about fitness. You need to constantly focus on the ground, plan your foot placement, and move quickly to changing conditions. This mental engagement can make trails feel tougher, especially when compared to the feeling of road miles.
But for most trail runners that mental challenge is also part of the fun.
4. More Effort And Planning (And Time)
Unless you live next to the trail then you need to think ahead for your trail runs.
You might need to run a couple of miles to get to the grass, or may need to drive to a trail head. Then you need to think about the extra kit you might want, like a pack, snacks and different running shoes, then there’s finding a good route, and knowing that running slower on trails means it takes more time.
All of that can be barriers for runners to overcome, especially when it’s easy to just put road shoes on and leave the house. But there are many benefits to trail running which makes it worth the extra effort.
The Benefits of Trail Running (and Why It’s Worth It)
1. Less Impact, More Longevity
While trails are more uneven, they’re also softer than the road, and this can reduce the impact on your body and lower the repetitive impact on your joints.
The lower impact forces (plus the extra effort it takes to get up those hills) can be great for long-term running health.
2. Improved Strength and Stability
Trail running is like extra strength work for runners.
Trails help to strengthen your main running muscles plus the stabiliser muscles, and it helps to improve balance and proprioception (or your sense of body position as you run).
This translates to better running economy and resilience, benefits that carry over to road racing.
In other words: training on trails can make you more efficient on the road.
3. A Mental and Emotional Boost
Running in nature has well-documented psychological benefits.
Studies on “green exercise” show that time outdoors can reduce stress, improve mood and boost motivation. Trail running can turn a training session into an adventure, offering mental refreshment that road running sometimes lacks. And you don’t need to climb a mountain for the benefits – any exercise in open green space is good.
In other words: we feel better when we run in nature.
4. You Learn to Run by Effort, Not Pace
Trail conditions can vary wildly — steep climbs, muddy sections, rocky descents — making pace an unreliable metric.
Instead, you learn to run by effort, tuning into your body and your breathing, which can make you a more intuitive runner. And that’s another great benefit that you can take with you to road running.
Trail Running vs Road Running: Which Is Better?
There’s no single answer and it all depends on your goals.
If you’re training for a road race, sticking mainly to roads helps you adapt to the specific demands of your race and lets you learn true race pace (but doing some trail runs will make you a stronger overall runner).
If you’re running for general fitness, strength or enjoyment (or for trail races), trails offer a more complete lower-impact workout and may come with added mental health benefits.
Mix trail and road and you’ll likely see the best of both worlds: endurance from the road, strength and stability from the trails.
Final Thoughts: Embrace the Trails!
Yes, trail running is harder than road running in many ways because it’s more demanding on your muscles.
But it’s also gentler on your joints, more rewarding mentally, and a brilliant way to build all-round running strength.
Next time you need a break from the pavement, hit the trails. You might slow down — but you’ll gain a lot more in return.
FAQS on Is Trail Running Harder Than Road Running?
That depends on the trails. If you’re on dry grass or light gravel then road shoes may be okay, but specific trail shoes will be more practical, especially if it’s muddy, challenging, rocky or has lots of roots. Trail shoes are better because they offer more protection against the elements and have better grip.
Trail shoes typically have a more structured upper to guard against mud and dust, and they might have more overlays or a toe protector/bumper to protect your feet. Then also have an outsole with deeper lugs and more traction, which is important to help with grip on difficult terrain.
‘Technical’ trails mean more challenging terrain. It’ll be steeper, have more obstacles like rocks and roots, and will take mental focus as well as physical agility to run (or hike, if it’s very technical). ‘Untechnical’ trails are usually fairly rolling with consistent underfoot conditions, typically meaning it’s more runnable.
READ MORE
Lead image from Maverick Race
